Soft Ice Cream
Certified Rich, Creamy & Delicious!
This classic treat is anything but ordinary! Our rich Soft Ice Cream is packed full of decadent flavor. Available in Vanilla, Chocolate & Swirl, order it in a cup, cake cone, or waffle cone with sprinkles OR better yet, layer it with our refreshing Italian Ice in a Jeremiah's Gelati!
The Gelati
The GelatiItalian Ice
Italian IceOur Flavors
The Line-Up = Standard Flavor
= Rotational Flavor
= Seasonal Flavor
Bahama Freeze
Who needs a vacation when you can be whisked away to the Bahamas with this refreshing twist of Strawberry, Lemon, Mango, and Coconut!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Banana
We know you'll go bananas when you take a bite of this frozen treat with fresh Banana slices in each scoop! Try "chilling" out with a Banana/Chocolate Gelati!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Black Cherry
Our bold, rich take on a classic cherry flavor.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Black Raspberry
Bold, dark flavor that can best be described as decadent!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Blue Cotton Candy
All the fun of your local carnival spun into a refreshing frozen treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Blueberry
Enjoy a colorful taste of childhood with this classic Italian Ice flavor!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Blueberry Limeade
The perfect balance of tart and sweet, resulting in a BERRY refreshing treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Caffe Latte
Caffeine addicts rejoice! Enjoy this Jeremiah's twist on a coffee house favorite.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Cake Batter
Tastes just like licking the bowl - without all the mess! Complete this tasty treat with a layering of rainbow sprinkles for a birthday twist!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Candy Cane Gelati
This refreshingly cool treat delivers a creamy, crunchy, minty blast with Peppermint Italian Ice layered with Vanilla Soft Ice Cream and Crushed Candy Cane.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Cherry
A classic Italian Ice flavor with an extra punch!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Chocolate
This classic Italian Ice is rich & decadent in all the right ways!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Coconut
Enjoy this rich and creamy Ice as visions of ocean waves and tropical sunny days whisk you away!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Coconut Lime
A tropical escape for your taste buds! Try it as a Coconut Key Lime Pie Flavorite!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Cookie Butter
A smooth and creamy treat featuring Biscoff Cookie Spread. Ride the wave of this latest dessert craze with Jeremiah's unique take on this spreadable goodness.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Cookies & Cream
Cookies & Milk meet Italian Ice with this classic flavor combination. This flavor is a fan favorite as a Chocolate, Vanilla, or Swirl Gelati!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Cotton Candy
All the fun of your local carnival spun into a refreshing frozen treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Gingerbread
Scoop up some Holiday Spice with our Gingerbread Ice!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Horchata
A Jeremiah's twist on a traditional Latin American beverage with vanilla and cinnamon flavors!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Key West Tropical
Take a trip down to the Keys with this tropical combination of Passion Fruit, Pineapple, Banana, Coconut, and Mango! And don't worry, sunburns aren't included.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Lemon
A zesty twist on a classic Italian Ice flavor.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Lemon Basil
Our 1st release in our Batch series has returned and it's sure to refresh and impress!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Mango
A fruity sensation that's become a Jeremiah's staple. Give it a try as a Mango/Vanilla Gelati for the ultimate tropical getaway!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Mango Margarita
Join the Cinco De Jeremi-O flavor fiesta in May and travel down to the white sand beaches of Mexico with this exciting twist on our classic Mango Ice.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Melon Fresca
This tasty Italian Ice packs a reFRESHing blast of tropical flavor!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Melonball
A classic, refreshing treat to get your day started off right!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Orange Smash
This treat is straight out of the grove! Try it as a Orange Smash/Vanilla Gelati for a classic Creamsicle flavor!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
P-Nutty
It's so easy to go nuts on this creamy treat. You might just order 2! Fans love this flavor as a P-Nutty/Chocolate Gelati to add a little extra decadence
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Passion Fruit
Looking for something a little exotic? Try this sweet and tangy concoction! Ramp up the decadence with a Passion Fruit/Vanilla Gelati!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Peach
Grab a succulent taste of the south with this refreshing Ice!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Pina Colada
A classic summer flavor featuring Coconut and Pineapple, this flavor is sure to transport your tastebuds back to the days of lounging by the pool in the sun.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Pumpkin Pie
From Slice to Ice! Jeremiah's unique twist on Grandma's holiday pie. We offer this flavor October to New Years to satisfy your pumpkin craving all season long!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Red Raspberry
Prepare for a flavor explosion like biting into a fresh, juicy raspberry! This flavor is sure to satisfy. Try it as a Red Raspberry/Vanilla Gelati!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Root Beer
Craving a root beer float? We've got your back! Try Jeremiah's rendition of this classic drink with a Root Beer/Vanilla Gelati!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Scoop Froggy Frog
This decadent, creamy treat is rich and chocolatey with a minty fresh twist!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Sea Salted Caramel
Ride the wave of decadent Caramel-y goodness with this salty and sweet Italian Ice.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Sour Green Apple
This tasty treat is sure to make you pucker up! Looking for something unique? Try a Sea Salted Caramel/Green Apple/Vanilla Gelati for a Caramel Apple treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Spicy Hot Chocolate
The decadence of rich hot chocolate with a festive dash of Jalapeno and Poblano to spice up your taste buds.
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Strawberry
This is a berrylicious classic! Looking to mix things up? Try a Strawberry/Cake Batter/Vanilla Gelati for a Strawberry Shortcake treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Strawberry Lemon
A tasty combination of our classic Strawberry and Lemon Italian Ice flavors. This refreshing flavor is a crowd favorite!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Sugar-Free Cherry
Looking for something sweet without the sugar? Let your taste buds fall in love with this refreshing treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Sugar-Free Sour Green Apple
Looking for something sweet without the sugar? Let your taste buds fall in love with this tangy treat!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Sugar-Free Tangerine
Looking for something citrus-y sweet but without the sugar? Our Sugar-Free Tangerine Ice is sure to fit the bill!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL
Watermelon
A go-to for fans of all ages, this refreshing flavor is sure to please!
3 Currently available at these locations
- Lake Mary - FL
- Maitland - FL
- Waterford - FL